The Relationship between Technical Progress and Employment: A Comment on Autor and Salomons
Levy Economics Institute, Working Papers Series, 2020
28 Pages Posted: 18 Feb 2020 Last revised: 14 Apr 2020
Date Written: February 3, 2020
We show that Autor and Salomons’ (2017, 2018) analysis of the impact of technical progress on employment growth is problematic. When they use labor productivity growth as a proxy for technical progress, their regressions are quasi-accounting identities that omit one variable of the identity. Consequently, the coefficient of labor productivity growth suffers from omitted-variable bias, where the omitted variable is known. The use of total factor productivity (TFP) growth as a proxy for technical progress does not solve the problem. Contrary to what the profession has argued for decades, we show that this variable is not a measure of technical progress. This is because TFP growth derived residually from a production function, together with the conditions for producer equilibrium, can also be derived from an accounting identity without any assumption. We interpret TFP growth as a measure of distributional changes. This identity also indicates that Autor and Salomons’ estimates of TFP growth’s impact on employment growth are biased due to the omission of the other variables in the identity. Overall, we conclude that their work does not shed light on the question they address.
Keywords: Employment, Labor Productivity, Technical Progress, Total Factor Productivity
JEL Classification: E24, O30, O47
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation