Unseen Equalization: Provincial Subsidies in Federal Programs

Fraser Institute, November 2013

53 Pages Posted: 9 Feb 2014

See all articles by David MacKinnon

David MacKinnon

Fraser Institute

Jane Loyer

Fraser Institute

Frazier Fathers

Fraser Institute

Milagros Palacios

Fraser Institute

Date Written: November 25, 2013

Abstract

In recent years, evidence has accumulated that regional subsidies incorporated in federal programs are substantial, affect all parts of Canada, and often have a direct impact on everyday life. These arrangements are not well understood because the funding directed to them is entwined with activities serving other purposes. Furthermore, the Government of Canada has never conducted a study of the economic impact of Canada’s comprehensive regional subsidy system. Consequently, with few exceptions, the resources being devoted to these programs, their impact on the economy, and the results being achieved are not evident to the public, governments, and legislators.

This paper provides an overview of the interprovincial redistributive effects of six selected areas of federal programming incorporating regional subsidies. These areas have been chosen because of their size, because they are ongoing rather than one-time interventions, and because they represent different types of programming. They include: Employment insurance; Disproportionate federal employment as a subsidy; Airport ground rental arrangements; Regional economic development agencies; Cultural programs, and; Immigration settlement.

Given that provincial subsidies can be built into programs as disparate as culture, airport rentals, and regional development, then it is probable that such subsidies are built into many other federal programs. The effect of many of the federal programs studied is to disproportionately support provinces east of the Ottawa River, and especially Atlantic Canada, at the expense of provinces west of it.

The regional subsidy system appears to be so big — much bigger than equalization on its own — that it is not sustainable in anything close to its current form. As it stands, this system discourages growth and development in traditional equalization-receiving provinces. Regional subsidies encourage excessive infrastructure and excessively large provincial public services, and, in the case of EI, they discourage labour mobility. They also enable the growth of public sectors in traditional equalization-receiving provinces that are much larger than in Ontario, Alberta, or British Columbia. These factors all discourage growth and adversely affect the people of these provinces.

Keywords: Government spending

Suggested Citation

MacKinnon, David and Loyer, Jane and Fathers, Frazier and Palacios, Milagros, Unseen Equalization: Provincial Subsidies in Federal Programs (November 25, 2013). Fraser Institute, November 2013, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2392593

David MacKinnon

Fraser Institute ( email )

1770 Burrard Street
4th Floor
Vancouver, British Columbia V6J 3G7
Canada

Jane Loyer

Fraser Institute ( email )

1770 Burrard Street
4th Floor
Vancouver, British Columbia V6J 3G7
Canada

Frazier Fathers

Fraser Institute ( email )

1770 Burrard Street
4th Floor
Vancouver, British Columbia V6J 3G7
Canada

Milagros Palacios (Contact Author)

Fraser Institute ( email )

1770 Burrard Street
4th Floor
Vancouver, British Columbia V6J 3G7
Canada

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
17
Abstract Views
854
PlumX Metrics