Common-Law Interpretation of Appropriate Education: The Road Not Taken in Rowley

Journal of Law and Education, 2011

41 Pages Posted: 21 Sep 2011

See all articles by Mark C. Weber

Mark C. Weber

DePaul University College of Law

Date Written: September 20, 2011

Abstract

Thirty years old in 2012, Board of Education v. Rowley is the case that established a some-benefit or floor-of-opportunity standard for the services public school districts must provide to children who have disabilities. But the some-benefit approach is by no means the only one the Court could have adopted. It could have endorsed the view of the lower courts that each child with a disability must be given the opportunity to achieve his or her potential commensurate with the opportunity offered other children. Or it could have adopted a standard based on achievement of the child’s full potential or the opportunity to become self-sufficient, or given some other meaning to the statutory term. This Article explores a different possibility: that the Court not have taken the case in the first place, or simply decided it on its facts without making any grand pronouncement about the interpretation of appropriate education. The result would have been caselaw development of the statutory term’s meaning in line with the evolution of the meaning of terms in other ambiguously worded statutes. This Article lays out the reasons that a common-law approach would have been the superior one. Persuasive analogies to other statutes support it; moreover, Rowley’s reasoning in reaching the some-benefit standard is highly unsatisfactory. Despite Rowley, many lower courts have marched along on something that strongly resembles a common-law road, but that cannot be given that name because of the Supreme Court’s decision. This Article concludes by pointing to cases that stretch the limits of the some-benefit standard and may represent the emergence of new approaches, as the traditional mode of common-law development would allow.

Keywords: education, special education, disability, civil rights, Rowley

JEL Classification: I20, J71, K39

Suggested Citation

Weber, Mark C., Common-Law Interpretation of Appropriate Education: The Road Not Taken in Rowley (September 20, 2011). Journal of Law and Education, 2011, Available at SSRN: https://ssrn.com/abstract=1931068

Mark C. Weber (Contact Author)

DePaul University College of Law ( email )

25 E. Jackson Blvd.
Chicago, IL Cook County 60604-2287
United States
312-362-8808 (Phone)
312-362-5448 (Fax)

Do you have a job opening that you would like to promote on SSRN?

Paper statistics

Downloads
168
Abstract Views
805
rank
211,937
PlumX Metrics