100 Horsemen and the Empty City: A Game Theoretic Examination of Deception in Chinese Military Legend
Journal of Peace Research, 48(2): 217-223, 2011
21 Pages Posted: 30 Oct 2010 Last revised: 4 Jun 2013
Date Written: August 15, 2010
We present game theoretic models of two of the most famous military bluffs from history. These include the legend of Li Guang and his 100 horsemen (144 BC), and the legend of Zhuge Liang and the Empty City (228 A.D.). In both legends, the military commander faces a much stronger opposing army, but instead of ordering his men to retreat, he orders them to act in a matter consistent with baiting the enemy into an ambush. The stronger opposing army, uncertain whether it is facing a weak opponent or an ambush, then decides to flee and avoid battle. Military scholars refer to both stories to illustrate the importance of deception in warfare, often highlighting the creativity of the generals’ strategies. We model both situations as signaling games in which the opponent is uncertain whether the general is weak (i.e., has few soldiers) or strong (i.e., has a larger army waiting to ambush his opponent if they engage in combat). We then derive the unique Perfect Bayesian Equilibrium of the games. When the probability of a weak general is high enough, the equilibrium involves mixed strategies, with weak generals sometimes fleeing and sometimes bluffing about their strength. The equilibrium always involves the generals and their opponents acting as they did in the historical examples with at least a positive probability. When the probability of a weak general is lower (which is reasonable given the reputations of Li Guang and Zhuge Liang), then the unique equilibrium always involves bluffing by the general and retreat by his opponent.
Keywords: deception, deterrence, bluffing, military history, signaling
JEL Classification: N45, D74, D82
Suggested Citation: Suggested Citation